Anyone ever tried these tires-I am desperately looking for an all season tire to replace my mich pilot a/s with since I was not all that happy. No matter which one I read about I always find something negative about them. These seem to have the overall best reviews but have no experience with either brands-anyone?

 

I had the Yokos on my previous vehicle, and was very happy with them. I have the Eagle F1 A/S now on my 530xiT, and am very pleased with them thus far. I think the Yokos might be a touch quieter, the eagles might be a wee bit stickier.

 

I take it you're looking at the stock sizes. Lots of choices Look at Tire Racks Comparison

 

Thanks guys-I did see that comparison but reading various reviews online someone or another ends up bashing a tire and I know you cant take every persons word but when something raises a red flag it sticks in my head so just wanted to make sure I was making the best informed decision.

In all honest the mich pilot sports are a fine tire in wet and dry. Cannot comment on snow but I drive the heck out of my car and they simplyl wear much to fast for the cost. Almost 260 a tire or something and after 6k miles the tread is at 4-5/32s that is not good