Window Tint and HUD
Thread Starter
Members
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 55
Likes: 0
From: Los Angeles, CA
My Ride: 2004 530i, Titanium grey/Black, Automatic, Sport, Premium, Nav, HUD, Aux input, 35% tint all around.
Ok, well that makes me feel better. It does only occur on very bright sunny days and just when the sun is positioned just so. I was alarmed as the first time i noticed it was when pulling out of the tint place.
Thanks for the feedback.
Thanks for the feedback.
Super Moderator
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 18,253
Likes: 0
From: FL
My Ride: F02 LCI Individual
Model Year: 2013
Originally Posted by buzzeroo' date='Sep 30 2004, 10:49 PM
Ok, well that makes me feel better. It does only occur on very bright sunny days and just when the sun is positioned just so. I was alarmed as the first time i noticed it was when pulling out of the tint place.
Thanks for the feedback.
Thanks for the feedback.
[snapback]39855[/snapback]
Super Moderator
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 17,310
Likes: 2
From: Pittsburgh, PA USA
My Ride: G30 M550i
Model Year: 2018
I agree with Iceman. I knew why he was asking the "blue" question and was waiting to hear the answer before I chimed in.
I've seen a blue glare only if the sun is at a specific (rare) angle. In my case, it happened when I had the sunroof open. The sun was behind me just enough to come in through the roof and hit the HUD just right. It was at a red light and once I was underway, the car moved enough to stop the glare. Rest assured that 99.9% of the time, I don't see the glare.
Also, rest assured that unless you tinted the windshield, polarized tint shouldn't make a difference.
I've seen a blue glare only if the sun is at a specific (rare) angle. In my case, it happened when I had the sunroof open. The sun was behind me just enough to come in through the roof and hit the HUD just right. It was at a red light and once I was underway, the car moved enough to stop the glare. Rest assured that 99.9% of the time, I don't see the glare.
Also, rest assured that unless you tinted the windshield, polarized tint shouldn't make a difference.
Looks like I have pull out the deadly scientific stuff.
The modern displays with LCD's work with polarized filters to allow the LC's to make a light or dark spot with an electric pulse. The HUD is an LCD image projected onto a reflective windscreen. If you wear sunglasses that are polarized, it kills the HUD image to nearly zero. If you tilt your head, the image returns because the polarization of the glasses no longer cancel the polarization of the display. So far, most of you know much of this physics.
Sunglasses are made for reducing glare from objects and water outdoors. The best results occur when the orientation of the polarizer is horizontal or close to that. Why?
Now the science....because the light from the sky on a sunny day is itself polarized. If you look at the blue sky with the polarizer filter, you will see that parts of the sky will be darker than others, until you rotate the polarizer and the darker part moves.
Thus, as you drive around on a sunny day, the angle of polarization of the sky 'light' relative to your window changes as you go north south east or west.
This is why a polarizer filter is standard for photographers outside to improve the picture. I see it on tv videos all the time too.
The modern displays with LCD's work with polarized filters to allow the LC's to make a light or dark spot with an electric pulse. The HUD is an LCD image projected onto a reflective windscreen. If you wear sunglasses that are polarized, it kills the HUD image to nearly zero. If you tilt your head, the image returns because the polarization of the glasses no longer cancel the polarization of the display. So far, most of you know much of this physics.
Sunglasses are made for reducing glare from objects and water outdoors. The best results occur when the orientation of the polarizer is horizontal or close to that. Why?
Now the science....because the light from the sky on a sunny day is itself polarized. If you look at the blue sky with the polarizer filter, you will see that parts of the sky will be darker than others, until you rotate the polarizer and the darker part moves.
Thus, as you drive around on a sunny day, the angle of polarization of the sky 'light' relative to your window changes as you go north south east or west.
This is why a polarizer filter is standard for photographers outside to improve the picture. I see it on tv videos all the time too.
Polarized tinting would filter the sunlight comming through and that is what changes with sun position. At some angle, the light falling on the optics of the HUD will be polarized 'the wrong way' and make a glare off the HUD viewglass windows very pronounced. The 'blue' glare color (on mine it is a little more purpleish) is the light reflected into and back out of the outermost mirrors and window of the HUD in the dash which, along the way becomes mostly bluish. There are coatings on the optics to keep heat from the sun out of the system. The hot color of the solar spectrum is red-infrared. This leaves blue-indigo to go through the optics easier and thus become the stronger color of light coming back out. The light path for the glare is completely different from the image generated by the LCD display. If polarizing tinting were put on the windsheild inside, it would have affected the HUD a lot unless its orientation was 90 degrees from that of sunglasses. This is unlikely the case, but easy to check with polarizing sunglasses from inside the car. This is why I don't think the tinting is polarizing by design but by accident in its manufacture.
More science: the lamination of plastic with glass that makes the windsheild structure also polarizes the the sunlight a little. That is why when looking at windows of other cars with polarizing sunglasses, they have that 'pattern'; you know what I am saying.
Without seeing the effect in person, the explanation remains speculation.
Thread Starter
Members
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 55
Likes: 0
From: Los Angeles, CA
My Ride: 2004 530i, Titanium grey/Black, Automatic, Sport, Premium, Nav, HUD, Aux input, 35% tint all around.
sg,
Thanks for all the great information. Let me see if I understand correctly. It sounds as if the tint I have placed on all windows (except windshield) may be causing the blue glare seen from time to time. Would this happen if the tint was not a polarizing tint? (i think my tint is llumar but i have no idea if it is a polarizing tint or not... i'll find out and post when i know).
Iceman made an earlier comment that he occasionally sees the blue glare and he does not have window tint. What would explain that?
Thanks again.
Thanks for all the great information. Let me see if I understand correctly. It sounds as if the tint I have placed on all windows (except windshield) may be causing the blue glare seen from time to time. Would this happen if the tint was not a polarizing tint? (i think my tint is llumar but i have no idea if it is a polarizing tint or not... i'll find out and post when i know).
Iceman made an earlier comment that he occasionally sees the blue glare and he does not have window tint. What would explain that?
Thanks again.



, very impressive