Turbo Failures
#21
Originally Posted by calpalmer' post='744425' date='Dec 13 2008, 09:08 AM
Where? Cites please? I think your statement may belie and misunderstanding of basic diesel combustion cycle chemistry; have you seen the temperatures that are reached? I think you're referring instead to improvements in materials of construction and to some degree cooling and lubricating efficiencies of modern engines.... But who am I to debate a Dr.... do what you like or advise others similarly. You may also rely to whatever degree you like on BMW's recommendations admonitions or lack thereof... these people also inform that many wear components and lubricants are "lifetime" "no maintenance required" .... wow! Unfortunately anymore manufacturers (not just BMW) consider lifetime to be 3-5 years and maybe 100K miles or so. We (American at least) consumers condition them to that marketing Hype and let them get away with it because, indeed, we buy our vehicles and them turn them over with a 3-5 year horizon. Very wasteful. High Carbon Footprint. Unsustainable. Etc. Etc. But again, each to their own and I in no way attempt to influence your behavior,
Cal
Cal
Diesel engines are more efficient than gasoline (petrol) engines of the same power, resulting in lower fuel consumption. A common margin is 40% more miles per gallon for an efficient turbodiesel; for example, the current model Skoda Octavia, using Volkswagen engines, has a combined Euro mpg of 38.2 mpg for the 102 bhp petrol engine and 53.3 mpg for the 105 bhp ? and heavier ? diesel engine. The higher compression ratio is helpful in raising efficiency, but diesel fuel also contains approximately 10-20% more energy per unit volume than gasoline. Diesel engines are also much more economical than gasoline (petrol) engines when at low or idling engine speeds, when they use very little fuel due to the precision nature of the injector system. Unlike the petrol engine, diesels lack a butterfly valve (choke) in the inlet system, which closes at idle. This creates parasitic drag on the incoming air, reducing the efficency of petrol/gasoline engines at idle. Due to their lower heat losses, diesel engines rarely run the risk of gradually overheating if left idling for a long period of time providing the cooling system is in good order. In many applications, such as marine, agriculture and railways, diesel-engined vehicles are left idling unattended for many hours or sometimes days. These advantages are especially attractive in locomotives.
pinched from rudolph diesels web site. i think it shows that diesel engines generaly run cooler than petrol, as was my point.
regards
david.
#22
Contributors
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 73
Likes: 0
From: Finland
My Ride: '09 LCI 520dA Business. Alpine White; Heated Standard seats in Beige Fusion Artificial Leather and Light poplar wood trim, high-gloss; Sport Steering Wheel; Automatic A/C with Extended features; Hi-Fi loudspeaker system; Cup holders; Cruise control with brake function; Heated ext. mirrors - folding, auto dimming; Xenons with Adaptive headlights and High-beam Assistant; PDC; Sunblinds for side and rear windows; USB interface; Extended Interior Lights Package; Soft-close doors; Windscreen with green shade band; Elec Fr Seats + Driver Memory; Smokers Package; Floor mats, velour
Originally Posted by Dr Dave' post='744467' date='Dec 13 2008, 05:45 PM
i think it shows that diesel engines generaly run cooler than petrol, as was my point.
#24
Senior Members
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 538
Likes: 0
From: Western Washington
My Ride: 2008 Space Gray 550i, Light Poplar Wood, Anthracite Head Liner, Sport Package, Sport Automatic Transmission, Cold Weather Package, Front Ventilated Comfort Seats in Black Nasca Leather, NAV, HUD, Active Steering, Comfort Access, Night Vision, Lane Deviation Warning, Active Cruise Control, Heated Rear Seats, Folding Rear Seats, Power Shade w/ Rear Side-Shades, Rear Air Bags, Logic 7, HD Radio, Sirius Satellite Radio, iPod/USB Adapter. Car in BMW Body Shop, estimated completion 01/24/07.
Originally Posted by Dr Dave' post='744467' date='Dec 13 2008, 07:45 AM
Diesel engines are more efficient than gasoline (petrol) engines of the same power, resulting in lower fuel consumption. A common margin is 40% more miles per gallon for an efficient turbodiesel; for example, the current model Skoda Octavia, using Volkswagen engines, has a combined Euro mpg of 38.2 mpg for the 102 bhp petrol engine and 53.3 mpg for the 105 bhp — and heavier — diesel engine. The higher compression ratio is helpful in raising efficiency, but diesel fuel also contains approximately 10-20% more energy per unit volume than gasoline. Diesel engines are also much more economical than gasoline (petrol) engines when at low or idling engine speeds, when they use very little fuel due to the precision nature of the injector system. Unlike the petrol engine, diesels lack a butterfly valve (choke) in the inlet system, which closes at idle. This creates parasitic drag on the incoming air, reducing the efficency of petrol/gasoline engines at idle. Due to their lower heat losses, diesel engines rarely run the risk of gradually overheating if left idling for a long period of time providing the cooling system is in good order. In many applications, such as marine, agriculture and railways, diesel-engined vehicles are left idling unattended for many hours or sometimes days. These advantages are especially attractive in locomotives.
pinched from rudolph diesels web site. i think it shows that diesel engines generaly run cooler than petrol, as was my point.
regards
david.
pinched from rudolph diesels web site. i think it shows that diesel engines generaly run cooler than petrol, as was my point.
regards
david.
Cal
#25
i do hear what your saying cal, and i agree with you, its far better to treat your turbo with respect and allow it to cool down so as not to run dry (due to heat which will dry out the barings).
but i still dont think that this is nessacery with an E60
the design of the M57 engine and materials used, would not allow "under normal driving" to warrent any cooling off period after driving.
the same could not be said for a petrol engine such as the subaru boxer turbo, which definatly requires a 30-60 second cooling off period in order to maintain baring life
modern diesel turbos do not require such "care" (although you can if you want to be pedantic)
hence no such warnings being given by the manufactures.
but as you rightly say, its each to there own.
but i still dont think that this is nessacery with an E60
the design of the M57 engine and materials used, would not allow "under normal driving" to warrent any cooling off period after driving.
the same could not be said for a petrol engine such as the subaru boxer turbo, which definatly requires a 30-60 second cooling off period in order to maintain baring life
modern diesel turbos do not require such "care" (although you can if you want to be pedantic)
hence no such warnings being given by the manufactures.
but as you rightly say, its each to there own.
#26
Thanks guys - It's good to know that they are solid - no swirl flaps and a reliable turbo should mean years of happy motoring!!!!
The ED Start/Stop works on Manuals only currently, and you have to stop, go into Neutral, apply the handbrake for shut down/stop. Then when you press the clutch the engine is fired by a heavy duty Alternator/Battery and NOT a starter motor. There is no cranking - it just purrs into life like a hybrid...
The ED Auto Trannnies have the new "toggle" like joy stick controller, so are partly ready. The Alternator techniology is missing but under development as far as I know...probably for the F10!!
The ED Start/Stop works on Manuals only currently, and you have to stop, go into Neutral, apply the handbrake for shut down/stop. Then when you press the clutch the engine is fired by a heavy duty Alternator/Battery and NOT a starter motor. There is no cranking - it just purrs into life like a hybrid...
The ED Auto Trannnies have the new "toggle" like joy stick controller, so are partly ready. The Alternator techniology is missing but under development as far as I know...probably for the F10!!
#28
Originally Posted by Jambers' post='744514' date='Dec 13 2008, 05:28 PM
Thanks guys - It's good to know that they are solid - no swirl flaps and a reliable turbo should mean years of happy motoring!!!!
The ED Start/Stop works on Manuals only currently, and you have to stop, go into Neutral, apply the handbrake for shut down/stop. Then when you press the clutch the engine is fired by a heavy duty Alternator/Battery and NOT a starter motor. There is no cranking - it just purrs into life like a hybrid...
The ED Auto Trannnies have the new "toggle" like joy stick controller, so are partly ready. The Alternator techniology is missing but under development as far as I know...probably for the F10!!
The ED Start/Stop works on Manuals only currently, and you have to stop, go into Neutral, apply the handbrake for shut down/stop. Then when you press the clutch the engine is fired by a heavy duty Alternator/Battery and NOT a starter motor. There is no cranking - it just purrs into life like a hybrid...
The ED Auto Trannnies have the new "toggle" like joy stick controller, so are partly ready. The Alternator techniology is missing but under development as far as I know...probably for the F10!!
#29
Hi all!
Long time no see.
I have now about 100k on odo and some hard driving on track and autobahns, but so far I have not payed much attension about cooling of engine/turbo. I think that more important it is to let engine heat up before pushed!
Like if you come out of The Ring, there is quite lot of time before one can find place to park, so that 30-60 sec "cooling" comes automatically.
And no! No any turbo problems and I have not heard so many in e60's. Couple though: one because valve went broken and through turbo and other because lack of oil due broken filter. Hardly no typical!
Skaffa
Long time no see.
I have now about 100k on odo and some hard driving on track and autobahns, but so far I have not payed much attension about cooling of engine/turbo. I think that more important it is to let engine heat up before pushed!
Like if you come out of The Ring, there is quite lot of time before one can find place to park, so that 30-60 sec "cooling" comes automatically.
And no! No any turbo problems and I have not heard so many in e60's. Couple though: one because valve went broken and through turbo and other because lack of oil due broken filter. Hardly no typical!
Skaffa
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Nyulak
E60, E61 Parts, Accessories and Mods
3
03-23-2016 07:22 AM
timmay77
E61 Touring Discussion
7
09-24-2015 09:38 AM
timmay77
E61 Touring Discussion
2
09-23-2015 12:34 AM