BesE60

I recently just hit a pot hole, bent my rim and changed into my spare.

My wheels before were style 138 on a 530XI... XI fitment the offsets were +43 standard 17 inch rims
Changed them as soon as I got home into Style 243 XI (17 inches) fitment with the same offset +43(08 530xi)
As I changed the backs they looked fine and all until I got up to the fronts. The wheels themselves fit onto the base but the fronts stick out past the fender, more specifically the side that I bent my wheel. Passenger side is about 1/4 inch out of the fender, will post pics tomorrow/tuesday, any ideas what it may be? My brother is handy and said it's fine but I'm a little weary