I'd go with the rep 172's there's been a lot of members with them. If one crack...which i never heard of because its not OEM lol...then replace it. Seriously quality issues on specific OEM wheels. Overpaid too.

 

i had a horrible experience with replicas..i bought two sets of style 166 replicas from here http://oemwheelsplus.com/ and they were crap...they were not able to balance ( i had 4 shops balance them ) brand new straight out of the box, my car had vibrations for over a year, until i recently put back my stock oem and vibrations went away...lesson learned