5Series.net - Forums

5Series.net - Forums (https://5series.net/forums/)
-   The Competition (https://5series.net/forums/competition-25/)
-   -   Lexus ES compares with.. ? (https://5series.net/forums/competition-25/lexus-es-compares-118873/)

crypto 11-13-2011 07:23 PM

Lexus isn't quite in the same ball park as the German manufacturers.. yet.. in my opinion, but I always thought the ES series from Lexus was on par with the 5 series or Merc E-Class. However, on the radio the other day I heard them comparing it to the BMW 3 series in terms of features and prices. They weren't targeting the 5 series drivers at all. I guess maybe the car is a bit more like the 5 series but their going after the 3 series market with pricing? Any thoughts? Doesn't matter much I suppose but I took note of it.

v_therussian 11-14-2011 12:21 AM

ES350 is a Camry. BMW 5 series is a thoroughbred.

/thread :thumbsup:

mark_hk 11-14-2011 04:53 AM


Originally Posted by crypto (Post 1398977)
Lexus isn't quite in the same ball park as the German manufacturers.. yet.. in my opinion, but I always thought the ES series from Lexus was on par with the 5 series or Merc E-Class. However, on the radio the other day I heard them comparing it to the BMW 3 series in terms of features and prices. They weren't targeting the 5 series drivers at all. I guess maybe the car is a bit more like the 5 series but their going after the 3 series market with pricing? Any thoughts? Doesn't matter much I suppose but I took note of it.


I guess the GS would be a "closer" match? At least the old GS300 we had in Hong Kong... with the 3.0 TT engine from Toyota Supra!!!

toyota2bmw 11-18-2011 06:19 PM

Don't do it!!! ES350 is a joke! GS300, except for the old GS300 is a joke too. Handles like a Camry/Avalon and has ZERO excitement! Stale as a week ol' bread if you ask me. I leased a decked-out GS300 in the past. It was the most painful 36 months I spent with a car in my life when I HAD to lease one for the wifey. We didn't look back a second when we returned it. What the hell were we thinking? At least the lease was cheap! Back in the ALL BMW stable now. :twoup:

dbae1978 11-18-2011 08:12 PM


Originally Posted by toyota2bmw (Post 1400397)
Don't do it!!! ES350 is a joke! GS300, except for the old GS300 is a joke too. Handles like a Camry/Avalon and has ZERO excitement! Stale as a week ol' bread if you ask me. I leased a decked-out GS300 in the past. It was the most painful 36 months I spent with a car in my life when I HAD to lease one for the wifey. We didn't look back a second when we returned it. What the hell were we thinking? At least the lease was cheap! Back in the ALL BMW stable now. :twoup:

Bah i think you should add a Merc to the stable hyung :hyper:

aretardedorange 11-19-2011 09:53 AM

ES350 is a terrible car unless you are 80+. It handles really bad. Its BORING. The torque steer is annoying. They compare it to the 3 series because of its price I think....? Then where does the IS go? :confused: The 5 gets compared to GS. If you are looking at jap brands it goes Infiniti>Acura>Lexus.

toyota2bmw 11-19-2011 10:49 PM

If the price point is n issue,there's always the CPOs. Nicely kept up cars for decent money with all the depreciation mostly paid for by the leasees. :twoup:

toyota2bmw 11-19-2011 10:53 PM


Originally Posted by dbae1978 (Post 1400412)
Bah i think you should add a Merc to the stable hyung :hyper:

I kinda liked my mom's CLS550. I of course will opt for the CLS63. Not really a fan of the new body style so if you come across one with the old body, let me know. :twoup: but then again, I still can't shake my craving for an E92 M3. :hyper:

swajames 11-22-2011 07:36 PM

Lexus has never positioned the ES against the 5 Series. It's an entry level near luxury, the same class as the 3 Series. The 3 outsells it. Still, the ES isn't a bad car, it's perfect for its intended audience.

I'll concede that BMW's by and large are better cars, but if you put the brand bashing to one side and give credit where it's due, it's worth remembering that Lexus has delivered something rather special in the LFA. The fastest BMW around the Nurburgring is the M3 GTS at 7:48. Lexus can do it in 7:14.

sdg1871 11-22-2011 09:47 PM


Originally Posted by swajames (Post 1401356)
Lexus has never positioned the ES against the 5 Series. It's an entry level near luxury, the same class as the 3 Series. The 3 outsells it. Still, the ES isn't a bad car, it's perfect for its intended audience.

I'll concede that BMW's by and large are better cars, but if you put the brand bashing to one side and give credit where it's due, it's worth remembering that Lexus has delivered something rather special in the LFA. The fastest BMW around the Nurburgring is the M3 GTS at 7:48. Lexus can do it in 7:14.

Yes the ES is perfect for its target market: those who want a very reliable, softly sprung car with a beautiful interior (we've had 2 in the family (my grandmother and father in law) so I speak from experience).

If you are going Japanese and are interested in more of a driver's car, the Infiniti M (I leased a M45 Sport for 4 years) and G and the Acura TL (my mother leases this and I have driven it a lot ) are much better picks. If you want a beautiful interior and a plush ride and great reliability then the ES is for you. If you love to drive, the ES's driving dynamics will put you to sleep.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:06 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands